10 Favorite Christmas Albums

I have included affiliate links below. When you purchase through these links, I may receive a small commission. Thank you for supporting this site and our sponsorship of our Compassion child, Samson!

I can’t let a Tuesday in December pass without mentioning my favorite Christmas albums and linking up with Amanda’s Top Ten Tuesday. Her post is genius today, by the way. Go check it out.

But I have a problem.

There are very few Christmas albums I’ve met that I don’t like.

So, I went with the ten that stick out most in my mind from over the years – and I’m just going to have to be ok with leaving some favorites out!


Top Ten Favorite Christmas Albums

(with a little help from my reindeer – just too cute to not throw this in!)

10. Glee Christmas {Vol. 1}

I JUST got this album yesterday and I love it already! Great song selection, awesome voices, upbeat and super fun!

9. Martina McBride – White Christmas

I don’t actually own this album right now, but my roommate in college did and it has stuck with me since. Martina’s voice is so beautiful and every song was just perfection.

8. Steven Curtis Chapman – All I Really Want for Christmas

Christmas is All in the Heart. Tears every time. I’m such a sap.

7. The Nutcracker

The Nutcracker is so magical. I fell in love with it while teaching elementary music and now delight in it with our boys!

6. John Denver and the Muppets – A Christmas Together

This was my absolute favorite growing up and their version of the 12 Days of Christmas cannot be beat. Period. (Ba-dum-bum-bum…)

5. Michael W. Smith – Christmastime

Emmanuel is probably my favorite on this but his version of Jingle Bells and Welcome to this World are amazing as well.

4. The Blenders – Nog

I am a sucker for a capella men’s voices so this CD grabbed me right away. Another one that I don’t currently own, but I did make a Blenders Christmas Pandora playlist so I can get that great big smile on my face. It is the perfect mixture of beautiful music and hilarity.

3. WOW Christmas (2002)

We’ve had this 2-disc set for a while now and I have never gotten tired of it. As on any compilation, there are songs I don’t really prefer, but they are far outweighed by gorgeous renditions of What Child Is This (MercyMe), God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen (Jars of Clay), Strange Way to Save the World (4HIM) and It Came Upon a Midnight Clear (Caedmon’s Call and a children’s choir that makes me cry EVERY. TIME).

2. Harry Connick, Jr. – When My Heart Finds Christmas

It would not be Christmas without Harry at our house. Such fun with It Must Have Been Ol’ Santa Claus and Parade of the Wooden Soldiers. And I love all of the big band style Christmas tunes!

1. Mannheim Steamroller – Christmas

This album came out in 1984. I was three. I think my parents had it then because Mannheim Steamroller is in every Christmas memory I have. I don’t even care that I can’t sing along. There is NOTHING like a synthesizer Christmas. No joke.


Ok, time to share your favorites! Because you know I don’t have enough already… 🙂